Sixty years of reasonable decisions, accumulated.
Vale & Co had been trading for sixty years and it showed. Four decades of seasonal campaigns, acquired sub-brands and well-meaning updates had left them with eleven logo variants, three typefaces nobody could name, and packaging that changed depending on which supplier happened to print it.
None of it was wrong, exactly. It had simply accumulated, one reasonable decision at a time, until the whole thing had no centre. Our first job was to lay every surface out in a single room and ask what the business would actually lose if each piece disappeared.
Most of it, as it turned out, nothing.


Rebuilt subtractively, from the shopfront lettering outwards.
We worked subtractively. Every element had to earn its place by doing something the others could not, and nothing decorative was allowed in before the structure underneath it was settled.
The wordmark was redrawn from the lettering on the original shopfront, tightened into a single weight and left alone. The palette came down to three colours, two of which are paper and ink. Six packaging formats became two, sized around what the warehouse already stocked.


A year on, the variants stayed gone.
The rollout began with the things customers touch first: bags, boxes, the receipt. These carry no imagery at all, only the wordmark and a great deal of space, which turned out to be the most expensive-looking decision in the project and also the cheapest to produce.
Staff were given a four-page guide instead of a sixty-page manual. A year on, the variants have not crept back, which is the only measure of a reduction that really counts.




